Smith carl Opiniões 

"SCAM ALERT! Carlos Trading is a total scam! They manipulated my account and now it's empty. Customer support is non-existent. DO NOT TRADE WITH THEM 💔"

I paid $2100 for a 6-month account management service, expecting professional risk management and capital protection.

Within less than 3 days, my account experienced approximately a 55% drawdown. This level of loss in such a short period clearly indicates excessive risk exposure and poor account management.

The trades were concentrated and used very large stop losses, which significantly increased the risk. This was not what I expected from a professional service.

After raising the issue, the company acknowledged internal mistakes and compliance breaches. However, instead of offering a fair refund of the subscription fee, they continued to push alternative solutions like “recovery plans” and account recapitalization.

I want to be clear: I am not asking for compensation of trading losses — only a refund of the service fee for a service that failed almost immediately.

Despite multiple attempts to resolve this professionally, the refund was refused.

Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this service.

I am working with Rose from last 6 months, who has been quiet helpful and gives personal guidance. irrespective of profit/loss she has been there with me always and planned out the things strategically

My experience with this company has been very disappointing and frustrating.

Initially, I was contacted by a representative named Zayn, who presented their trading services as professional and well managed. Based on these assurances, I paid service fees and deposited funds into a trading account. The trading was conducted according to his instructions and recommendations.

Very soon, the trading resulted in significant losses. After these losses, I was contacted by another representative, Zoey, who introduced herself as a colleague and assured me that the situation would now be handled in a more professional way. She promised a more responsible and structured approach to managing the account. Unfortunately, the result was exactly the same. The trading again led to further losses, and once again no one from the company took responsibility for the outcome.

Some time later, Zayn contacted me again and offered other services that required very large deposits. I insisted on starting with smaller amounts. After some time, Zayn offered another service that he claimed would follow a completely different approach compared to the previous one. In order to limit further risk, I insisted on defining clear rules for trading and risk management. These rules were mutually discussed and agreed upon. However, already the following day Zayn ignored these agreed rules. When I pointed this out, he did not acknowledge any mistake and instead insisted that such behavior was normal.

Throughout our communication, I repeatedly asked for transparent and professionally managed trading, clear accountability, and proof of consistent performance before committing any additional funds. Instead, the discussion repeatedly shifted toward encouraging further deposits and additional service packages.

When the situation became unacceptable, I tried to resolve the matter fairly. I offered the company a reasonable solution: I requested only a refund of the service fees I had paid and explicitly stated that I would not demand compensation for my trading losses. Despite this attempt to resolve the issue amicably, I did not receive any meaningful response from the company. Zayn stopped taking responsibility for the situation, and communication from the company’s support team stopped entirely.

Based on my experience, the level of professionalism, transparency, and accountability was far below what I would expect from a company offering financial services. I strongly recommend that anyone considering working with this company proceed with extreme caution.

Pure gamblers here, Stay clear away. This is basically bunch of Indian Scammers dogging people in the name of FX trading. They don't know how to trade. All they do to blow your account.

I paid $200 enrollment fee to manage account with $500 capital. They made £400 in the same day but blown the whole account in very next day!

No risk management, no price action strategies, no back up plans. Pure gambling. They executed at least 300 treads with $500 capital! So you can imagine the level of competence.

And they asking to recapitalise again! And said to them to get lost.

If you don't wanna loose your money with this incompetent and inconsiderate gumblers, just stay away.

All the positive feedback you see Al here are made by their own people in India. Not genuine at all.

Thank you for reading this honest review.

I have been working with this company Carlos&Company for a short time and I can only say that this cooperation with them is correct and honest, and their employees are very friendly, especially Miss Jennifer, So all praise from my side.

As a beginner I was greeted by Lily and she made understand the analysis, and place some really good signals.

I've been working with Jennifer for a few weeks now, so far everything is fine and she's fulfilling her work and communication responsibilities.

The company was very helpful and made me winnings for the past 4 months.. i am really happy with the results and i recommend to choose carlos and company as your trusted trading company especially Jennifer that was taking care of my account and made for me very high earning.

Service was great. Gave me insights on specific areas that I need to learn and new being a new guy. Lily was accomodating and pleasant to talk to.

I learned about this company through a post on X. Then I joined their WhatsApp channels. I was very impressed by the accuracy of the signals they shared. I contacted Alvin James. He gave me detailed information about the services they provide. They are also a customer-focused company when it comes to payments. They help with everything. They answer all your questions instantly. I'm happy to be able to withdraw money from my account after a long time. I want to work with them for a long time. My special thanks to Alvin James.

I am extremely satisfied with the support and guidance provided by Alvin James from Carlos and Company. His professionalism, clarity, and deep understanding of the trading process made the entire experience seamless. Alvin offered timely assistance, transparent communication, and reliable insights that truly added value. I genuinely appreciate his dedication and the way he ensures every client feels supported. Highly recommended for anyone looking for trusted guidance and exceptional service.

Es la primera vez que urilizo este servicio .Para empezar no tengo experiencia.Robin este persoana de contact y me ayuda en todo.Las senales son bastante buenos y espero que vaya todo bien Gracias

Totally scam , dont believe them ..

Scam .. i gave 200$ for basic signals the first week was good the guy charlie told me i would make a profit of 1200$ per month bullshit i asked them to return my money didnt reply to that message then changed my rm to jennifer they all have fake names thank god i didnt invest much with them

Fantastici,mandano dei segnali spettacolari.
Super affidabili,vale il prezzo.
10/10

I have been with the team working with them from 10 months, and my experience have been great enough with the perfect analysis that Charlie gives and the kind of professional team maintains with timely updates is highly appreciated. Also the timely strategical changes aligned with the market is well analysed.

updated ---- > NEW OPINION

Im working with this company and im followed by Robin, in one week he made 18 signals and 16 of them were all positive, in one week we have made +300% profit, until now we are working good and l hope we continue like this!

I was writing with them for 1 month they gave me 4 signals 2 wrong and 2 good. I was thinking they might be legit. Then I asked about company details and they send me one company not from Dubai, but Sharjah, which everyone can make. Then I asked them about the Indian license and address. They didn't provide.. Should I keep going. The contacts on LinkedIn all look suspicious and scam. DON'T PAY THEM ANYTHING!!!!
IF THEY OFFER 1 free month of signals to see how good they are MAYYYYBE. AND STILL DON'T